Knitters come in lots of varieties and styles. One of the most common distinctions is the question of whether a knitter is a process knitter or a product knitter.
But what if you’re not sure? What if you might be a little bit of both? What if you don’t even know what those terms mean?
The truth is that, as with most dichotomies, this one only goes so far. Most of us fall somewhere in the middle and can have tendencies of both process and product knitters, depending on the day and the project.
In today’s blog post, we’re going to look at what exactly defines a process knitter versus a product knitter, when it can be helpful to have that distinction, and when those distinctions obscure more than they clarify.
Process v. Product Knitter: What the Terms Mean
First, let’s define our terms. A process knitter is a knitter who knits for the act of knitting. They may like the rhythm, the repetitive motion, the feeling of yarn in their hands, whatever.
A product knitter, on the other hand, is motivated by the finished object they will have when they are done knitting. Maybe that’s because they want to wear the finished item themselves, or maybe it’s because they want to give it as a gift to someone.
Like the kiki versus bouba conversation, it can be fun to sort things into two overbroad categories and debate which specific item (or person) fits into each category.
For practical purposes, these labels can be helpful when we want to loosely categorize different types of people. When we are talking at a macro level, being able to sift and sort populations is a helpful thing, even if it is inexact. Among knitters themselves, it can be a useful shorthand for talking about why we knit in the first place.
Why the Labels Can Be Useful
As with personality types, like the Enneagram or the MBTI, these labels for different kinds of knitters can be a quick and easy way of explaining how and why different knitters do things differently.
A knitter who can work for hours on a plain garter-stitch scarf, who doesn’t mind frogging, and who will cheerfully reuse yarn from one project to knit another can easily explain these tendencies by saying they are a process knitter. If the end result isn’t the most important part of the process, then it doesn’t really matter how long it takes to get there or whether you even end up keeping the finished knit.
On the other hand, a knitter who cranks out vast quantities of hats, each of them in a different style, can also use these labels as a useful shorthand. They are a product knitter. They are building a hat collection, and they want the collection before the coldest part of winter hits.
Where the Labels Fall Short
The biggest challenge with these labels, of course, is that most categorization breaks down to some extent on the individual level. Trends across populations are rarely perfectly replicated in any single member of that population. That’s why, even though demographers will observe broad generational trends, you might not necessarily feel a strong connection to your own generational cohort.
The same thing can happen with these categories. Although it’s common for process knitters to not mind frogging, that’s not universally true. Some process knitters love knitting for hours on simple garter stitch, while other process knitters only like tackling really complicated projects. Both are knitting for hours with no end in sight and no rush to reach the end, but the actual process looks very different.
On top of that, many of us exhibit elements of both process and product knitting tendencies at different times. For example, a knitter might be more of a process knitter when working on their own projects and a product knitter when working on a gift. Some people can find these labels stifling as a result.
My Own Experience with Process v. Product Knitting
As for me, I’ve pretty much always been a mix of both. When I started knitting, I chose projects based on whether they contained a new skill I wanted to learn and whether I liked the finished item.
Nowadays, I’m still looking for projects that are fun to knit and that will fit into my life. Some of those projects take forever, like the Mitered Square Blanket of Doom. That was definitely mostly a process knitter project.
Other projects are more product-focused, like the silk version of my Frontispiece Scarflet that I knit last summer. I already had one scarflet, but I wanted to knit a version in silk so I could wear it during the warmer summer months. That project was almost entirely product-driven. I was actually kind of bored knitting two versions of the same project so close in time to each other.
A Different Question to Ask Yourself
While it’s totally fine to use the process knitter and product knitter labels, I also like to look a little more closely on an individual project basis. Instead of asking myself what kind of knitter I am, I ask myself why I’m tackling that particular project.
Do I need it by a certain time? Am I making it for myself or for someone else? Am I making it because I want to learn from it or because I want the finished item?
And sometimes, I’m a different knitter on different days. That’s why I like to have a few different projects going at the same time. Then, depending on how I feel that day, I will have a project that’s a good fit.
Whatever Kind of Knitter You Are, That’s Just Fine
One last note: often, I see discussions of different kinds of knitters devolve into a debate about which type is better. There is no type of knitter that is better than another.
Whether you are a process knitter, a product knitter, or somewhere in between, you are engaging in a very special fiber art that connects you to others across time and borders. We all have something we bring to the table, and we all have something to learn from each other.
Let’s stay connected!
Join my newsletter for 30% off all new releases, regular updates with helpful tips and tricks, first crack at registration for upcoming workshops, exclusive discounts, and more.
I’m on YouTube now and would love to have you join me there for regular project updates, technique tips, chats about goings-on in the knitting world, and more.
Prefer to read without ads? Join my Patreon, which starts at just $1 a month!
Join the A Bee In The Bonnet Facebook Group to participate in knitalongs and other fun community events
Come hang out with me on the A Bee In The Bonnet TikTok
Follow along on the A Bee In The Bonnet Instagram
Get inspired via the A Bee In The Bonnet Pinterest
